Homeowners across Arizona have built equity in their homes, and that equity can sometimes provide access to funds for a remodel, debt consolidation, a large expense, or other financial goals. But deciding to use home equity is only the beginning of the conversation.
Two common ways to access that equity are a home equity line of credit (HELOC) and a cash-out refinance. While both use the equity in your home, they work very differently.
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a new, larger mortgage and provides the difference, after applicable costs and payoff amounts, as cash. A HELOC generally leaves your existing first mortgage in place and adds a separate revolving line of credit secured by your home.
Which is better? There isn’t one answer that works for every Arizona homeowner.
Your current mortgage, available equity, how much money you need, what you plan to use it for, current interest rates, costs, and how you prefer to repay the money can all influence the decision.
Before comparing loan products, it helps to understand the homeowner’s starting point.
When someone contacts me about accessing their equity, there are several things I want to understand first:
Those answers establish a baseline. From there, another important question is how the homeowner expects to use the funds.
Do you need a smaller amount today but expect additional expenses in the future? Or do you know approximately how much you need and prefer to receive the money as a lump sum?
That distinction can help determine which option deserves a closer look.
A home equity line of credit, or HELOC, allows homeowners to borrow against a portion of the equity they have built in their home. It generally works alongside the existing mortgage, giving the homeowner a separate source of funds that can be accessed as needed.
During the HELOC’s draw period, you can generally borrow from the available credit line as needed, subject to the terms of the loan. As you repay borrowed funds, you may be able to access the line again during that period.
That flexibility can make a HELOC worth considering when expenses will occur over time rather than all at once. A multi-stage home renovation is one example.
However, flexibility isn’t the only consideration.
HELOCs commonly have variable interest rates, and some allow interest-only payments during the draw period. That can affect both the monthly payment today and what the homeowner will be required to pay later.
Understanding the rate structure, draw period, repayment period, fees, and how payments could change should be part of the decision.
A cash-out refinance works differently.
Instead of adding a second loan, you refinance your existing mortgage into a new mortgage for more than the amount you currently owe. The existing mortgage is paid off, and the homeowner receives a portion of the difference as cash after applicable costs and other payoff requirements.
This can provide a defined lump sum for needs such as:
Depending on the loan selected and the homeowner’s qualifications, a cash-out refinance may also provide the predictability of a fixed-rate mortgage and consistent principal-and-interest payments.
But there is an important tradeoff: you are replacing your existing mortgage.
For many Arizona homeowners, that makes their current mortgage rate one of the most important parts of the analysis.
Today’s HELOC versus cash-out decision can look very different for a homeowner who already has a low-rate first mortgage.
Many homeowners obtained mortgages when rates were below 5%. Replacing one of those mortgages with a new, higher-rate loan simply to access equity may not always make financial sense.
That doesn’t automatically mean a HELOC is the better choice.
I like to look at the current first mortgage, the amount of additional money needed, and the potential cost of the new borrowing together. Comparing that combined or “blended” borrowing cost with the available cash-out refinance options can provide a more useful picture of the tradeoff.
For example, keeping a low-rate first mortgage while borrowing a smaller amount through a HELOC may be worth considering. In another situation, the combined cost of maintaining the first mortgage and adding a HELOC could make refinancing the entire balance worth evaluating.
This is why looking only at the advertised rate of a HELOC or the rate of a new first mortgage doesn’t tell the whole story.
Understanding how mortgage rates work can provide helpful context, but the decision should be based on the homeowner’s complete borrowing picture.
The biggest difference is what happens to your current mortgage.
| HELOC | Cash-Out Refinance | |
|---|---|---|
| Existing mortgage | Typically remains in place | Replaced by a new mortgage |
| How funds are accessed | Revolving credit line | Lump-sum proceeds |
| Interest rate | Commonly variable | May be fixed or adjustable depending on the loan |
| Payment structure | Can change and may include an interest-only draw period | Based on the terms of the new mortgage |
| Borrowing approach | Borrow as needed during the draw period | Borrow a defined amount at closing |
| Loan position | Typically a separate lien | New mortgage replaces the existing first mortgage |
| Costs | Vary by lender and program | Refinance closing costs and other applicable charges may apply |
These differences are important, but they still don’t make one product inherently better.
The right question is how those differences fit your situation.
A HELOC may deserve consideration when a homeowner wants to preserve the terms of an existing first mortgage, particularly if that mortgage has a favorable rate.
It can also be useful when you don’t need all the money at once.
Suppose you’re remodeling a Phoenix-area home and expect contractors, materials, and other project expenses to occur over several months. Having access to a credit line may offer more flexibility than taking the entire amount upfront.
A HELOC may also be considered when the amount needed is relatively small compared with the existing mortgage balance.
But homeowners need to be comfortable with the loan’s terms. If the HELOC has a variable rate, the cost of borrowing and monthly payment can change. An interest-only payment during the draw period can also look attractive initially without showing what payments may look like once repayment of principal is required.
A cash-out refinance may be worth evaluating when the homeowner knows how much money is needed and prefers receiving a lump sum.
It may also be considered when restructuring the existing mortgage and accessing equity together produces a borrowing arrangement that better fits the homeowner’s goals.
The intended use of the money matters here too. A homeowner consolidating certain debts may have a very different objective and timeline than someone funding a remodel or increasing available liquidity.
That’s why the decision shouldn’t be based solely on whether a new mortgage produces a lower monthly payment.
Look at what happens to the loan balance, interest rate, loan term, closing costs, and total borrowing picture.
Our Mortgage Refinance Loans resource explains more about refinancing and the factors homeowners should consider before replacing an existing mortgage.
One of the most important parts of this conversation is understanding what you’re actually comfortable paying and what each option costs.
With a HELOC, I first want to know whether the homeowner is comfortable with an adjustable rate and potentially an interest-only payment structure during the draw period.
With a cash-out refinance, we can look at the proposed rate and payment, but we also need to look at the new loan amount.
Refinance costs may sometimes be financed into the new mortgage rather than paid entirely out of pocket. That can reduce the amount needed at closing, but it also means the homeowner should understand how much the mortgage balance is increasing.
A lower payment by itself doesn’t necessarily mean a loan is less expensive.
The same principle applies when reviewing a HELOC. Compare the amount of the credit line and funds available to you with the fees and costs associated with establishing the line.
The objective is to understand what you’re receiving, what you’re paying for it, and what the borrowing arrangement could cost over time.
Homeowners should be cautious when someone pushes too hard for either a HELOC or a cash-out refinance before understanding the full situation.
There are legitimate reasons to consider either option.
There are also situations where accessing home equity may not be the right move at all.
A mortgage professional should be willing to analyze the homeowner’s existing loans, available equity, intended use of the funds, payment preferences, qualification requirements, and the costs associated with each available option.
The goal shouldn’t be to fit every homeowner into the same product. It should be to understand the alternatives well enough to make an informed decision.
If you’re uncertain which option makes sense, the first step doesn’t have to be choosing a loan.
It can simply be understanding your position.
When I review an equity scenario with an Arizona homeowner, we start by determining whether there is enough available equity to accomplish what they’re trying to do.
Then we talk about the purpose of the funds.
Is this for a remodel? Paying down other debt? A major expense? Or does the homeowner simply want greater access to liquid funds?
The reason for accessing the equity can affect which strategy fits the situation.
From there, we can discuss how an appraised property value could affect the available equity, review the existing mortgage and any other liens, and consider qualification factors that may influence the available options.
Then we can compare the potential payment structures, rates, costs, and longer-term implications.
Sometimes that analysis points toward a HELOC. Sometimes a cash-out refinance is worth considering. A closed-end second mortgage, sometimes called a HELOAN, may also be worth evaluating for homeowners who prefer a fixed-rate second mortgage rather than a variable-rate line of credit. And sometimes the best decision may be to leave the existing mortgage and equity alone.
Your home equity can be a valuable financial resource, but accessing it creates debt secured by your home. The decision deserves more than a quick comparison of rates or monthly payments.
For Arizona homeowners, especially those who already have a favorable first-mortgage rate, the starting point should be the entire financial picture:
If you previously considered whether refinancing makes sense, our July guide, Should You Refinance? When It Makes Sense, provides additional context for evaluating your existing mortgage before making a change.
If accessing your equity is the next question, Schedule Today for an equity strategy review. We can look at your existing mortgage, available equity, goals, and potential options so you can compare the numbers before deciding what makes sense for you.
Justin Toenjes (ten-yes) is a highly accomplished finance professional with a strong background in mortgage banking and a passion for helping individuals achieve their financial goals.
Join 900+ Subscribers and updated on the newest posts by Toenjes Home Loans.
Loan Officer – Justin Toenjes – LO Licensing: AZ-LO-0912116, CO-100032832 | NMLS-167048 | NMLS-6274
LO Licensing: Kathi Alosi, AZ-LO-0914249 NMLS-259189
Peoples Mortgage – 11201 N Tatum Blvd, Suite 140, Phoenix, AZ 85028
Company Licensing: Peoples Mortgage Company, A DBA of Moria Development, Inc. AZ-BK-0904164, CO – Regulated by the Division of Real Estate | NMLS-6274 www.peoplesmortgage.com/privacy-policy – Regulated by the Division of Real Estate peoplesmortgage.com/license NMLS-6274 (Equal Housing Lender)
Peoples Mortgage: 2055 E Centennial Circle – Tempe, AZ 85284
By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies in your browser to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and provide our ad partners with information for ad personalization and measurement. Please see our ‘Privacy Policy‘ for more information.
